I Hate When You Put on the God Costume

Omnipotence – an agency or force of unlimited power

George Sr. - Arrested Development - Wearing the God Costume

I was told at a forum that I went to on education reform by a man who had a PHD in Education Policy that, “teachers are the most important factor in aiding whether or not a student succeeds.” I was struck by this comment. Not because I haven’t heard it before, but because someone with a PHD in education policy would ever utter those words. I thought to myself, Me? The most important factor in student success? I must be God.

Rhetoric regarding education reform is full of this level of unrealistic omnipotence. There is an alarming level of complacency in the idea that the teacher is the centre of education and the answer to failing schools is centred on addressing the inadequacies in the teachers across the country. Moreover, the omnipotent rhetoric doesn’t end with just attacking teacher “ineffectiveness;” it also exists in discussing the solutions to fixing failing schools.

Education reform will not come to past if there is a continued filter of omnipotence that guides rhetoric and policy. Rhee argued in her Student’s First Mission Statement that “[o]nce inside the school, a great teacher is the single most important factor in a child’s education. While there are many factors that influence a student’s ability to learn, a great teacher can help any student overcome those barriers and realize their full potential.” Can Michelle Rhee explain to a teacher how they are supposed to help a student “overcome” living in a home with lead paint and being subjected to lead poisoning through their developmental years? Can Michelle explain to a teacher how to help a student “overcome” the barrier of a father who is sexually abusing her, and the local child protective services say, “There is no evidence to prove that this child has been abused, because she is sexually active?” Can Michelle Rhee explain to a teacher how to help a student overcome the “barrier” that is in place for a student who is so exhausted when he comes to school because his parents get in physical altercations that keep him up nightly? These are all examples of students that I’ve had in the past, whose “barriers” stifled their “full potential.” The student with lead poisoning had to be placed a severe learning-disabled self-contained classroom, because he only read at the second grade level (he was in 10th grade). The student, whom was being abused by her father, killed herself because despite my (and other teachers) best efforts, she felt that no one could save her. The student, who witnessed daily domestic violence, watched his mother being killed and went into a deep depression because he was essentially an orphan. As much as these situations pained me, and still do to this day, I know that I did my best to help these students. It is my awareness that I am not omnipotent that keeps me going to help the students who have a lesser degree of personal circumstances. However, to Michelle Rhee, I am an ineffective teacher because each of those students was failing my class when their lives changed forever.

I wish I could say that these are unique problems that many teachers, who work in the toughest schools in this country, deal with. The problems that plague our schools are so much deeper than any one inadequate teacher, the bureaucracy of the teachers unions, the layout the teacher evaluation system, and the rigour of the state standardized tests. The problems that plague schools are historic, economic, racial, and societal. This is why I am confident that Michelle’s “RHEEforms” aren’t omnipotent, regardless of the number of billionaires, media outlets, and filmmakers that are on her side. There is no simple solution, and the mere fact that the Student First’s mission statement is nonchalant in “the factors that influence a student’s ability to learn” implies that solutions are omnipotent.

Principals? Administrators? the Federal Government? Angels?

The Student’s First blog featured a video that was a compilation of teachers, who were concerned about school reform, and one teacher’s comments gave me pause.

“When we have to contract out how many hours a teacher spends, how many hours they get paid after school…how many hours they have to be on school premises…that is not putting kids first.” – Barbara, Learning Specialist

Additionally, in an interview with nj.com, Michelle Rhee argues:

“I don’t think we need to reform tenure. I don’t think there is a need for tenure. Teachers need to understand they are not going to be discriminated against. If they feel they’ve been unfairly terminated, they need to have a process by which they can address that issue. School districts need to ensure firings are not happening in an unfair manner. But all of those things can happen without tenure being in place. [T]here are federal protections in place against discriminatory firings.”

In both the statements by Barbara and Michelle Rhee there is an “air of omnipotence” that seasons their rhetoric. The “air of omnipotence” is demonstrated here in three forms:

• Teachers are not human; therefore they should give all of their time, effort, and energy towards educating students with little to no compensation.
• Principals and other administrators are infallible; therefore they will not subject teachers to any practices that may be deemed discriminatory.
• If a non-infallible principal happen to slip through, then the omnipotent anti-discrimination laws by the federal government (you know…the law that makes sure that women and men are paid the same) will protect them and their reputation while they go through the courts.

I am sure most of you reading this are thinking that these statements are ludicrous. Nevertheless, this is the nature of their rhetoric. This is what happens when you scapegoat one group of people in a system with a lot of players. There is an unrealistic precedent created that will not lead to the reforms needed. This is why the Due Process (pejoratively known as “Tenure”) and teacher’s unions are important. These two elements of the educational landscape do their best to level the playing field for the people who work with STUDENTS day in and day out. While I will never assert that teacher’s unions are infallible and omnipotent, stripping the landscape of these two entities only serve to leave unrealistic expectations for all players. When I was unfairly fired from a charter school a couple of years ago, I created/adopted a mantra that I will always believe: “As long as schools are run by people, we will always need unions.”


About mpal219
Educator, Student, Reader, Reformer, & Activist

5 Responses to I Hate When You Put on the God Costume

  1. Renee says:

    Great article and right on point. Keep writing and thinking—you are bound to be one of those educators who comes up with some solutions instead of problems.

  2. Frustrated Science Educator says:

    this was so enlightening.. i agree with everything that was said. We are currently dealing with this situation at my job, being blamed for the failures of students and being told that we are not doing enough. Even though most of the teachers are contacting parents, having students see them after school, offer tutoring (that no one attends) etc etc. What is to be said about the lack of parental involvement? How do we fix societal issues that plague our students? How do we deal with the students who are suffering from PTSD after having guns pointed at them and their personal effect taken? Or who are jumped by other students from other schools?Students who only eat when in school, and once school is over they are released to environments that are unstable? How are we as educators supposed to then take these kid and mold them into perfect test scores? It is easy to point the finger at educators, we are after all with our students more than their parents are.. but how about attacking this problem at the root? How about EDUCATORS being involved in the reform process and not people who have some other agenda.. Until we start equally funding schools, looking at societal, racial and economic issues.. things will never change and these issues will continue to fester

    • mpal219 says:

      I agree with you 100%… which leads me to believe that education “reform” is a cover for something else deeper. I think it’s time for educators to uncover the veil of deception.

  3. Ha – yes – God – all teachers: Gods….if only….

    I do think it’s important that we keep in mind that teachers are very important – although much research emphasizes they are the most important “in-school” factor, which is significant. I’m not suggesting this post did this, but I’m afraid teachers are too often quick to defend the profession by implying that quality teaching is somehow not important. Rhee and like-minded reformers are certainly capitalizing on distracting the public from some of the more serious issues regarding education, but rather than denying teaching is important, teachers need to remind those less informed that teachers are primarily wary about the way corporate reformers suggest we hold teachers accountable. Again – I realize this post did not make this mistake, but I think it’s important to point out.

    And on Rhee and tenure…..phew – get rid of tenure and it will make it that much easier for TFA to staff more and more schools. First in first out is definitely not ideal, but given the current atrocious reality of standardized testing and a government that sees firing an entire staff as meaningful reform – tenure is something the profession needs to hold on to.

    • mpal219 says:

      I agree with you 100% I never want to imply that the quality of teaching is important. I really want to make the statement that teachers are only one part of the formula and that EVERYONE involved including the teachers must be working at the optimal level (this includes the people inside and outside the school e.g. police, social agencies, etc.) “Correcting” or “reforming” schools will absolutely not be the only catalyst of change needed for these students because there are problems that exist outside the school that make even “a world class education” worthless.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: